Why the ASUS ProArt P16 (2025, RTX 5090) Makes a Compelling 16″ MacBook Pro Alternative
At a Glance
-
A 16″ 4K (3840×2400) 16:10 OLED touchscreen, 120 Hz refresh, 0.2 ms response time, up to ~1,600 nits HDR peak brightness, 100 % DCI-P3 gamut, Pantone-validated. (Ultrabookreview.com)
-
Powered by AMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 370 (12-cores/24-threads) + NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 Laptop GPU (24 GB VRAM) in the top config. (Notebookcheck)
-
64 GB LPDDR5X RAM, dual SSD support (up to 4 TB), WiFi 7, USB-C/USB4 ports, SD Express 7.0 card reader. (Ultrabookreview.com)
-
Weight ~1.95 kg (≈4.3 lbs) and chassis designed for creators – a mobile workstation rather than a pure ultra-thin. (Ultrabookreview.com)
How It Compares to the 16″ MacBook Pro
The 16″ MacBook Pro is widely regarded as the top choice for many creatives because of its excellent display, battery life, ecosystem, and build quality. However, for users who want Windows + NVIDIA GPU + wider I/O + touchscreen and are willing to trade some battery/efficiency, the ProArt P16 presents a highly attractive alternative.
Advantages over MacBook Pro:
-
Discrete high-end NVIDIA GPU (RTX 5090): If your workflow uses CUDA/OptiX, or you do heavy 3D, rendering, GPU-accelerated AI/ML, the P16 offers a Windows/NVIDIA environment that the MacBook Pro (with Apple Silicon) might not match in terms of certain GPU frameworks.
-
Creator-centric I/O: Full-size SD card reader (SD Express), USB-A + USB-C + USB4, HDMI 2.1 – more flexibility for pro gear without dongles.
-
Top-tier display for visual work: The OLED panel here is not just sharp but extremely color-accurate and HDR capable; one review calls it “one of the best displays among laptops in 2025”. (Superfashion.us)
-
Touchscreen + pen support: Many MacBook Pros lack full touch/pen support. The P16 gives creators another dimension of input.
-
Windows software compatibility: If you rely on software that is Windows-native (some pro-apps/plugins), or prefer flexibility of the Windows ecosystem, this is a strong draw.
Trade-offs compared to MacBook Pro:
-
Battery life: While excellent on spec, the P16 will likely not match the ultra-long battery life of Apple’s silicon machines under light loads. For heavy GPU work it will consume significantly more power.
-
Efficiency & silence: MacBooks often run very cool and quiet, especially during light tasks; with the P16 you’re dealing with more heat, more active cooling under load. (One review: “fan noise ramps up under load” though still quieter than many gaming-laptops.) (Superfashion.us)
-
Software/driver/user-experience polish: Apple has a tightly integrated hardware/software ecosystem; Windows machines still face variability (drivers, updates, hardware-specific quirks).
-
Price & value: A top configuration with RTX 5090 will be costly (several thousand USD). You're buying high-end specs, not a budget substitute.
-
Reliability & quality control: Some user reports raise concerns (see “What to watch” below).
What Works Especially Well
For creative professionals whose workflow includes tasks such as:
-
4K/8K video editing, color grading, motion graphics
-
3D modeling, rendering, VFX, GPU compute tasks
-
AI-powered creative workflows (e.g., image/video generation, machine learning inference)
the ProArt P16 hits sweet spots: large, accurate display; powerful GPU; good I/O; portability enough for mobile studio work.
Some real-world review highlights:
“Colour reproduction is simply outstanding… panel covers 100% DCI-P3 … one of the most color-accurate laptop screens available in 2025.” (Superfashion.us)
“3DMark Time Spy produced a GPU score of roughly 18,400 … while thicker 175 W gaming rigs with the same GPU typically hover around 22–23 K.” (Superfashion.us)
A full spec list notes: “100% DCI-P3, Delta E <1, Pantone Validated, HDR peak ~1,600 nits.” (Fstoppers)
So if your priority is “power + accuracy + Windows ecosystem”, this laptop can be a very strong alternative to a 16″ MacBook Pro.
What to Watch / Consider Before Buying
-
Thermal & sustained-load behavior: The RTX 5090 in this machine is around 120W TGP, which is lower than some bulkier gaming laptops. Reviews note it will perform superbly, but it’s not the full desktop‐equivalent rate of a large chassis. (Superfashion.us)
-
Build & reliability concerns: While many users are happy, there are threads noting issues such as random crashes, boot loops, or service-experience frustrations.
“My ASUS Proart P16 … has broken down TWICE within 6 months of purchase, both times with total data wipe.” (Reddit)
“My … screen turns off and on for a second… the laptop is very slow and laggy.” (Reddit)
This doesn’t mean “don’t buy”, but means you should check warranty/support in your region, ensure BIOS/driver updates are current, and if possible buy from a trusted channel. -
Battery life will depend heavily on workload: For light work, you’ll do fine; but for heavy GPU/CPU loads it won’t hit the multi-day unplugged times you might see with Apple silicon in optimized workflows.
-
Portability trade-offs: Although ~1.95 kg is quite portable for a 16″ workstation machine, it’s still heavier/bulkier than ultra-thin “MacBook type” machines. If you prioritize ultra-light travel over raw power, there may be lighter options.
-
Pricing: The top spec will be expensive (4K USD+ or equivalent). You’ll want to compare whether you truly need the RTX 5090 + 64 GB + 4 TB, or if a slightly lower tier would suffice for your workflow.
-
Software ecosystem: If your workflow is deeply tied into the Mac ecosystem (Final Cut Pro, Logic Pro, etc) you’ll want to ensure the Windows alternatives meet your needs — power alone isn’t everything.
My Verdict
If I were to summarise:
Yes — the ASUS ProArt P16 (RTX 5090 edition) is among the best Windows-based 16″ alternatives to the MacBook Pro, especially for creators who want maximum GPU power, wide I/O, and a pro‐grade display.
At the same time: if your workflow is more mobile/light-weight, or optimized for Mac OS and its battery/efficiency strengths, a MacBook Pro could still be the better fit.
If I were deciding today, and my workflow involved heavy GPU tasks + I valued color accuracy + Windows ecosystem, I’d be very comfortable choosing the ProArt P16. But I’d also set realistic expectations: it’s a workstation-class machine, not ultrabook-class.
If you like, I can compare head-to-head this ProArt P16 vs the current 16″ MacBook Pro models (M4/whatever Apple offers in 2025), highlight the pros/cons of each for creative workflows (video editing, 3D, AI, color grading). Would you like that?